2/29: What Can "The Public Historian" Teach Us About the State of the Field?

Race, History, and the Politics of the Local by Elizabeth Belanger

Eizabeth Belanger is an associate professor of American studies at Hobart and William Smith colleges in Geneva, New York. She is an academic historian of women’s history, urban studies and historical geography. Her article “Race, History, and the Politics of the Local” focuses on the assurances and risks of public historians working in their communities. Belanger discusses People’s History Martin Luther King Jr. Day Civil Rights curriculum unit which is a collaboration between middle school and undergraduate students to create a local civil rights public art/history project (Belanger, 43). She uses theories of whiteness, white supremacy, and white privilege to analyze this public history project in response to the National Council on Public History which called on “white public historians to engage in the work of dismantling white supremacy in public history practice…” (Belanger, 44). Belanger’s work and project would be considered historic preservation as she aims to preserve local history as it pertains to historical events such as Geneva’s public schools making Martin Luther King Jr.’s birthday a school holiday and schoolchildren and parent boycotts in response which lasted from 1972 to 1976 (Belanger, 49). She outlines three contexts that shaped this practice and examines how they each served to privilege whiteness. The first is the production and practice of history in which Belanger’s students researched newspaper coverage of the school holiday debate which included black voices filtered through white lens and also the voices of white school administrators and board members. There was an abundance of sources of white voices, but finding black voices that were not filtered through a white lens was more difficult (Belanger, 52). This led students to ask how structural racism is embedded in historical records and how they can fail to recognize Black voices. So, Belanger’s students decided to conduct oral histories; but they faced difficulties as some potential interviewees did not respond and wanted to remain silent. They found a community consultant and conducted an oral interview which stood in contrast to official records of the events (Belanger, 54) and helped students confirm local newspaper bias. Students were also able to connect past history to present problems facing Geneva’s black community. The second is the timelines, tensions, and urgency in K-16 schooling in which Belanger identifies problems of contested history from prominent community members who didn’t want their names involved in the project as it revealed their past biases. Belanger also focuses on reflection as a defining skill in public history practice (Belanger, 56). Finally, the last context was community, collaboration, and shared authority in which Belanger touches on how a public historian's own bias can shape their understanding of community and collaborators. Based on Belanger’s writing, her project can most definitely be considered “radical public history” due to the challenging of the dominant narrative, political uses, contested history, and her use of theories of whiteness.


Remembering the “Dade Massacre”: Regional Memory, Settler Colonialism, and Native American Perspectives by Daniel S. Murphree

Daniel Murphree is an associate professor in the history department at the University of Central Florida. He is an academic historian who specializes in early American history with an emphasis on Native Americans in Florida. His article “Remembering the ‘Dade Massacre’” focuses on the creation of the Dade Massacre historical site, its interpretations, and how they shaped historical memorialization in public spaces in Florida and the Deep South (Murphree, 108). In addition, Dr. Murphree is examining the role of the settler colonialism theory and Native American perspectives for the sites change over time to the present day Dade Battlefield Historic State Park. Dr. Murphree’s article represents historic site management due to the interpretation of the site’s history, preservation, and management over time. This piece could be considered radical public history due Dr. Murphree’s examination of the lack of Native American interpretations in the Dade Battlefield Historic State Park. Dr. Murphree states that there is little indication of “engagement over the years with settler colonialism theory or Native-centered perspectives by park interpreters is concerning” and raises the suggestion that there is “a long history absent of broader context and interpretive debate.” (Murphree, 132). This article reminded me of Elizabeth Belanger’s in that both examine voice; whether it is a white lens or Native American lens. It also questions historians' own biases when defining and understanding this history without Native American voices.


We and Bobby Lee: Public Historians and the Fight to Remove Confederate Memorials by Jason Pierce and Michael Powers

Jason Pierce and Michael Powers are associate professors from Angel State University. This article focuses on the role of the historian in history memory and commemoration and as advocates of movements by nonacademic community members. More specifically, the authors aim to address how historians can combat Lost Cause narratives with their expertise (Pierce & Powers, 63). This piece represents historic preservation sites and the recent movement of Confederate monument removals. In the case of Robert E. Lee Middle School, it was a grassroots efforts movement in San Angelo, Texas, to change the name. Both authors are professors at the local university and believe that their support of a name change prompted their belief for “the necessity of historians participating in public discourse and social movements in important and strategic ways.” (Pierce & Powers, 65). This concept hinges on the collaborative and supportive effort historians should engage in with members of the community. This article touches on shared authority and allyship with marginalized communities (Pierce & Powers, 65). It also represents radical public history due to the political debates surrounding Confederate monuments and the advocacy of marginalized communities initiatives.


Black California Dreamin’: Claiming Space at America’s Leisure Frontier by Alison Rose Jefferson, curator

This is an exhibition review of the Black California Dreamin’ exhibition at the California African American museum. The exhibition focuses on black spaces of leisure in Southern California during the early-to-mid twentieth century. This article is about museum curation and the benefits in creating meaningful community relationships. In the case of the Black California Dreamin’ exhibition, curator Alison Rose Jefferson used community relationships to “yield important artifacts, stories, and perspectives on public historical questions.” (Jefferson, 107). Jefferson combined artifacts from area repositories with family items, film footage, textiles, and contemporary art. This can be considered radical public history due to the use of community artifacts that relate to leisure which argue that despite Jim Crow segregation, Black Californians were able to create their own spaces; thus challenging the dominant narrative.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

1/18: Historic Eatonville and the Fight to Preserve “America’s First Incorporated Black Town” in the 21st Century

1/25: The History Harvest as Community-Engaged, "Hands-On" History