Posts

3/28 Reading: Thomas Cauvin, Public History: A Textbook of Practice / Historians as Consultants and Advisors

A Textbook of Practice Thomas Cauvin begins the introduction by talking about how popular history is in mainstream culture such as television and game shows. However, he says there's a lack of authority meaning that historians aren’t a part of popular historical reflection. He cites Robert Rosenzweig and David Thelen who conducted a survey on the presence of the past in American everyday life in 1998. They said that people prefer creating their own versions of the past rather than seek those prepared by others (Cauvin, 1). Cauvin argues that “historians may be completely absent from the most popular representations of the past.” (Cauvin, 1). He gives a popular example of people using genealogical websites that generally don’t have any historian collaboration. He is touching on the divide between being a traditional historian or public historian. In doing so, he is reasserting the need for history and historians (Cauvin, 2). Cauvin also “aims to show how historians can participate i...

3/14: The Inclusive Handbook

About the handbook: The Inclusive Historians Handbook is sponsored by the American Association for State and Local History (AASLH) and the National Council on Public History (NCPH). The handbook was published in 2019. The purpose of which is to give advice, offer perspectives, and share practices that promote an inclusive history.  Diversity and Inclusion:  There has been a growing discourse in public history that there is “limited scope of representation within the historical narrative.” Thus conversations about diversity and inclusion have increased over the years. This part of the handbook focuses on “drawing distinctions between the terms and further exploring inclusion, both in terms of social sinclusion and workplace inclusion” (Taylor). Because diversity is a broad term that can many different things, diversity and inclusion consultant Michael L. Wheeler defined it as a dynamic force that drives change. In addition to defining diversity, author Chris Taylor define incl...

3/7: Preserving & Interpreting Historic Cemeteries as Public Memorials & Educational Resources

This week's readings go over the history and debates of preserving cemeteries as public memorials and educational resources. The topics included three case studies on the Greenwood Cemetery, Daughters of Zion Cemetery, and Shockoe Hill African Burying Ground. The location of these cemeteries have to do with the politics that surround them. Greenwood is located in the South while the Daughters of Zion Cemetery and Shockoe Hill are both located in Virginia, which is an important site of national historic memory.  Greenwood Cemetery is the only burial grounds controlled by the City of Orlando. The role of the public historian is an ongoing initiative by students at the University of Central Florida. Sarah Boye has spearheaded the preservation of Greenwood Cemetery as historical site. With the help of other UCF students, she incorporated digital elements of preserving Greenwood with a walking tour on Clio.  Daughters of Zion Cemetery located in Charlottesville, Virginia, is a hist...

2/29: What Can "The Public Historian" Teach Us About the State of the Field?

Race, History, and the Politics of the Local by Elizabeth Belanger Eizabeth Belanger is an associate professor of American studies at Hobart and William Smith colleges in Geneva, New York. She is an academic historian of women’s history, urban studies and historical geography. Her article “Race, History, and the Politics of the Local” focuses on the assurances and risks of public historians working in their communities. Belanger discusses People’s History Martin Luther King Jr. Day Civil Rights curriculum unit which is a collaboration between middle school and undergraduate students to create a local civil rights public art/history project (Belanger, 43). She uses theories of whiteness, white supremacy, and white privilege to analyze this public history project in response to the National Council on Public History which called on “white public historians to engage in the work of dismantling white supremacy in public history practice…” (Belanger, 44). Belanger’s work and project would b...

2/22: Andrew Hurley, Beyond Preservation: Using Public History to Revitalize Inner Cities

Beyond Preservation:Using Public History to Revitalize Inner Cities by Andrew Hurley argues that historic preservation using public history is an effective tool for inner-city neighborhoods. Hurley states that historic preservation "invigorates local economies but strengthens communities by nurturing a deeper attachment to place, greater levels of social cohesion, and a collective agenda for local development" (Hurley, ix). Historic preservation should incorporate public interpretation at the grassroots level in order to better attune to the needs of local communities. For Hurley a part of this approach includes acknowledging the history of these communities. Chapter 2: Taking it to the Streets This chapter explores the emergence of social history and its impact for marginalized communities. Hurley argues that in order to view the potential of public history as a tool for revitalization, there needs to be an examination of democratized and professionalized interpretation of u...

2/15: Shared Authority, Shared Inquiry, and Radical Roots

What is "shared authority" and "shared inquiry"? Michael Frisch popularized the concept of shared authority in the late 1980s (Cauvin,  216). The shared authority concept means that everyone--scholars and the public--has a role in oral history thus contributing to the shaping of history. Thomas Cauvin suggests that shared authority can be done "through inviting visitors attending exhibitions to share their stories and interpretations of the collections, through collaboration with narrators in creating oral history sources, or through developing online crowdsourcing projects" (Cauvin, 216). But he acknowledges that "shared authority" is an ongoing debate within the scholarship community. Cauvin argues that if public historians collaborate with the public in their work they can attract broader audiences (Cauvin, 217). Katharine T. Corbett and Howard S. (Dick) Miller define shared inquiry as a key component of reflective public history practice (Cor...

2/8: Reading: Denise Meringolo, Radical Roots : Public History and a Tradition of Social Justice Activism

Radical Roots: Public History and a Tradition of Social Activism Introduction and Conclusion Radical Roots: Public History and a Tradition of Social Activism is a collaboration of scholars who share a commitment to social justice and the field of public history. Denise Meringolo defined radical public history as “future-focused, committed to the advancement of social justice, and engaged in the creation of a more inclusive material record.” (Meringolo, 2). The historiography of radical public history began in the late 1980s and 1990s with the work of Peter Noviak. His scholarship identified the separate paths of history and public history while shedding light on public history's purpose to preserve historic structures, commemorate historical events, develop museums and historic sites, acquisitions of collections, and interpretation of the past for the general public (Meringolo, 5). In this book various scholars look to the origins of radical public history in the aftermath of socia...