2/15: Shared Authority, Shared Inquiry, and Radical Roots

What is "shared authority" and "shared inquiry"?

Michael Frisch popularized the concept of shared authority in the late 1980s (Cauvin,  216). The shared authority concept means that everyone--scholars and the public--has a role in oral history thus contributing to the shaping of history. Thomas Cauvin suggests that shared authority can be done "through inviting visitors attending exhibitions to share their stories and interpretations of the collections, through collaboration with narrators in creating oral history sources, or through developing online crowdsourcing projects" (Cauvin, 216). But he acknowledges that "shared authority" is an ongoing debate within the scholarship community. Cauvin argues that if public historians collaborate with the public in their work they can attract broader audiences (Cauvin, 217). Katharine T. Corbett and Howard S. (Dick) Miller define shared inquiry as a key component of reflective public history practice (Corbett et al., 15). This is a collaborative approach between scholars and the public that involves discussion and interpretation of historical sources.

On Radical Is a Process: Public History Pedagogy in Urban Universities by Rebecca Amato, Gabrielle Bendiner-Viani, Dipti Desai, Denise D. Meringolo, and Mary Rizzo

This essay was authored by a group of female academic workers in the realm of public history who share a commitment to social justice pedagogy. This piece began as a conversation at the November 2017 National Humanities Conference. They argue that radical pedagogy should extend beyond institutions and emphasize the importance of personal and political orientations in teaching. They stress the value of engaging in dialogue with students and community members with differing beliefs, advocating for humility and listening as core values in the humanities. They believe that engaging with minorities by recognizing their voice is true radicalism. The participants also share their answer to the question on how to make radical work sustainable when universities don’t actively support partnerships with community organizations (Amato et al., 326). For their jobs, they emphasize a partnership between students and community partners. The article then goes on as a conversation on each project they are working on:

Denise Meringolo created the Preserve the Baltimore Uprising digital collection project in response to protests after the death of Freddy Gray in police custody. She created the project in order for protestors to control their own message and she modeled it after other social justice digital collections on police brutality (Amato et al., 327)

Dipti Desai works on the Community Book of Wellbeing which is a collaborative effort between graduate students in the Research in Art and Education course at NYU and partners with the Commission on Public Health Systems in NYC. This project uses the arts to find new ways of working within “community settings to inspire dialogue about issues of concern to the community in order to initiate social change.” (Amato et al., 327).

Rebecca Amato created an undergraduate community research course at NYU called Displaced Urban Histories in partnership with community-based organization Women’s Housing and Economic Development Corporation. The course focuses on history-based neighborhood change and is predominantly produced for the South Bronx community rather than a university audience (Amato et al., 328). 

On sustainability, the scholars address their concerns and thoughts. Denise Meringolo believes that once projects become sustainable they rely on departmental funds, get tied to programs of study, and lose connection from the communities they intend to serve. Instead, she believes that we should think of sustainability “as something achieved through capacity building” (Amato et al., 344).  Mary Rizzo believes that the goal of sustainable projects is the connections the relationships made with community partners; which is a belief shared by other scholars. Other scholars believed in long-term projects in order to establish and maintain trust with communities while creating meaningful social change (Amato et al., 347). 

On shared authority and inquiry in Radical Is a Process: Public History Pedagogy in Urban Universities

I thought this article showed great examples of shared authority and shared inquiry. These projects were not created for academic reasons, but rather a contribution to collaborative efforts with communities and a chance for them to become involved in the conversation. The academics are not necessarily experts but rather facilitators of creating community dialogues about social change.



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

2/29: What Can "The Public Historian" Teach Us About the State of the Field?

1/18: Historic Eatonville and the Fight to Preserve “America’s First Incorporated Black Town” in the 21st Century

1/25: The History Harvest as Community-Engaged, "Hands-On" History