2/22: Andrew Hurley, Beyond Preservation: Using Public History to Revitalize Inner Cities
Beyond Preservation:Using Public History to Revitalize Inner Cities by Andrew Hurley argues that historic preservation using public history is an effective tool for inner-city neighborhoods. Hurley states that historic preservation "invigorates local economies but strengthens communities by nurturing a deeper attachment to place, greater levels of social cohesion, and a collective agenda for local development" (Hurley, ix). Historic preservation should incorporate public interpretation at the grassroots level in order to better attune to the needs of local communities. For Hurley a part of this approach includes acknowledging the history of these communities.
Chapter 2: Taking it to the Streets
This chapter explores the emergence of social history and its impact for marginalized communities. Hurley argues that in order to view the potential of public history as a tool for revitalization, there needs to be an examination of democratized and professionalized interpretation of urban areas (Hurley, 32). To do this Hurley examines the contributions of nonacademic social groups in public history. The emergence of social history ("peoples history") also gave rise to debates between popular and academic history. This convergence provided "a potent force for democratizing the history found in public places" (Hurley, 35). The concept of shared authority and an "usable past" changed historical preservation in urban areas (Hurley, 38). In addition, Hurley looks at public archaeology that includes grassroots preservation. He argues that public history and public archaeology could achieve more than want they currently offer. This collaboration could "tailor public-history programs to concrete revitalization outcomes" (Hurley, 54).
Chapter 5: Making a Place for Nature
This chapter was my assigned reading for the week and focuses on historic and environmental preservationists. Hurley argues that integrating the natural and built environment for healthy communities may be the next frontier of urban historic preservation (Hurley, 120). In the 1980s, integrated natural and cultural features in preservation began to emerge (Hurley, 122). National Heritage Areas were classifications for areas that promoted environmental and historical preservation. Hurley believes that land trusts are also an effective tool in saving properties that are important cultural resources. In this course we have talked about the possible use of a land trust for the town of Eatonville as the idea has been supported by the mayor. Hurley says that land trusts occur when “a group of individuals pool their re- sources and form a nonprofit, tax-exempt organization that exists solely to acquire property and take it off the market to prevent development.” (Hurley, 123). Hurley goes on to talk about revitalization efforts of communities due to the legacy of industrialization. An environmental justice movement emerged during the 1990s to address the impact of ecological degradation on poor, minority areas (Hurley, 124). Hurley talks about public history projects on the environmental issues in communities like The National Environmental Health and Justice Literacy Project which aimed to engage citizens in environmental issues through history (Hurley, 126). Urban areas that have been abandoned and taken over by natural elements also benefit from restoration and preservation. Hurley states that these places can serve the community as converted gardens or parks which aid in historical preservation (Hurley, 130). On the potential of waterfront revitalizations not just for tourism, Hurley points to a recent push toward the needs of local communities. These advocates have developed waterfronts using environmental preservation, public history, and economic development (Hurley, 132). All of this supports Hurley’s argument that landscape preservation and interpretation is a great tool for revitalization and community bonds (Hurley, 144). Hurley also advocates for the integration of preservation methods and urban planning. But, he acknowledges the challenges this might face given private property and financial incentives for preservation. However, small-scale initiatives employing a holistic approach can be viewed as important steps toward preserving sustainable urban patterns (Hurley, 145).
How might this book inform our thinking about Eatonville and the development of the Hungerford School property?
A question that has been floating around our classroom since the beginning of the semester is how to use public history to attune to the needs of the township of Eatonville. This book identifies the benefits and challenges to historic preservation. One solution for Eatonville has been a state-sponsored African American history museum which community activists such as John Beacham do not want to see happen. Throughout this book Andrew Hurley discusses the importance of integrating public interpretation and thought in historic preservation. Although creating historic districts are important in terms of tourism and help rejuvenate neighborhoods, it leaves out issues impacting local communities. Therefore, John Beacham's concerns about a museum placed in Eatonville are not absurd as it will not solve the issues of the community, but rather create a source of income for the Florida government. Eatonville needs more than a museum to solve their issues. The Association to Preserve the Eatonville Community has done a good job incorporating resident opinion in their plans for the future. However, Orange County has yet to join them in the conversation.
Comments
Post a Comment