2/8: Reading: Denise Meringolo, Radical Roots : Public History and a Tradition of Social Justice Activism

Radical Roots: Public History and a Tradition of Social Activism Introduction and Conclusion

Radical Roots: Public History and a Tradition of Social Activism is a collaboration of scholars who share a commitment to social justice and the field of public history. Denise Meringolo defined radical public history as “future-focused, committed to the advancement of social justice, and engaged in the creation of a more inclusive material record.” (Meringolo, 2). The historiography of radical public history began in the late 1980s and 1990s with the work of Peter Noviak. His scholarship identified the separate paths of history and public history while shedding light on public history's purpose to preserve historic structures, commemorate historical events, develop museums and historic sites, acquisitions of collections, and interpretation of the past for the general public (Meringolo, 5). In this book various scholars look to the origins of radical public history in the aftermath of social movements from the mid-20th century. What makes "radical" public history is the scholars who aim to create an inclusive historical record while simultaneously challenge oppression (Meringolo, 16). In the conclusion, Meringolo urges the importance of scholars to recognize the radical roots of public history. This includes, "recognizing the impact that historical trends have had on the development of radical forms of public history," which, "provides us [scholars] with a clearer view of both the promise and the shortcomings of politically engaged historical work.” (Meringolo, 609).

Allan Nevins Is Not My Grandfather: The Roots of Radical Oral History Practice in the United States by Daniel R. Kerr

This article is split into five sections to discuss the origins of public history and its development and use overtime by practitioners. In the first section of this article, Kerr goes over historiography of oral history beginning with Allan Nevins, who established the oral history project at Columbia University in 1948. But Kerr states by casting Nevins “as the founder of oral history promotes a simplistic view of what oral history is; it also misrepresents its development over time.” (Kerr, ?). Kerr inserts the arguments of two scholars: Linda Shopes and Joan Sangster. Both of whom begged the question was there ever really a “theoretical turn in oral history," while questioning the origins of development. Kerr outlines the purpose of this article which acknowledges that Allan Nevins legitimized the field of oral history within academia; and while he does not intend to replace the founding mythology of oral history he does intend to reflect on the sources for his own work and use that understanding to trace a forgotten branch of oral history genealogy. He is also looking at contributions that have “been erased or devalued” by the Nevins narrative.

In the second section of his article, Kerr challenges the origins of oral history by looking back to the 1930s and Myles Horton. Horton was a socialist who helped create the Highlander Folk School with his socialist connections. And with his work he developed the practices for working with personal narratives in which Kerr says would play a pivotal role in the work of oral historians who followed (Kerr, 27). The Highlander school participated in social movements like industrial unions and civil rights through conducting workshops for grassroots leaders. Horton used “a two-eye theory” of instruction by keeping one eye on the point people started from while focusing the other eye on where they might arrive (Kerr, 28). Through this approach he created a “circles of learners” which refers to the workshop staff not to direct the learning but rather create an atmosphere where participants listen to each other's stories and share their personal experiences freely (Kerr, 28). This approach keyed in on members’ knowledge and analyzed problems to learn how to transform their society from the bottom-up. This inspired the creation of Citizenship Schools which brought the Highlander workshop approach to Black communities in the South (Kerr, 29). This drew the attention of civil rights organizations such as the Southern Christian Leadership Conference who took over the Citizenship Schools program in 1961. The Highlander approach was embraced by leaders like Ella Baker who believed in the agency of people while inspiring others to embrace a radical and democratic approach to community organizing. A leader who emerged was Staughton Lynd, who Kerr says “played a pivotal role in translating the core principles of adult popular education into the field of oral history.” (Kerr, 30) After being blacklisted from academia for his antiwar activities, he and his wife moved to Chico and engaged in “guerrilla history” which focused on oral histories with rank-and-file workers (Kerr, 30). Their histories were intended for other industrial workers to use as a tool for further dialogue. The Lynds’ work inspired a new generation of oral historians and are associated with the disciplines “theoretical turn.” (Kerr, 31)  Paulo Freire, who did not identify himself as an oral historian and was also blacklisted, published Pedagogy of the Oppressed in 1968 and argued “that in critical pedagogy, oppression and its causes were the “objects of reflection by the oppressed.” (Kerr, 32). Freire shared similar views as Horton. Freire developed his synthesis in which “educators identified with people’s ideas and posed them as a problem from consideration by the people themselves.” (Kerr, 33). Finally, Helen Matthews Lewis was a founder “of the field of participatory action research and a self-proclaimed oral historian,” who became one of the first U.S. popular educators to use Freire’s work. Kerr states that Lewis encouraged researchers in communities to ask themselves “Where does accountability lie?” (Kerr, 34).

The third and fourth sections of Kerr's article examines how historians utilized the people's history movement and declination and critique of their approach. After social movements of the mid-20th century and work of practitioners in public history, historians drew inspirations of those of the past and “organized dozens of people’s history projects across the United States.” (Kerr, 35). These projects included the Massachusetts History Workshop, Brass Workers History Project, Baltimore Neighborhood Heritage Project. Each project utilized the oral histories of their prospective communities while making, "significant contributions to the way many historians and activists think about the past, and they informed a broad array of social justice movements." (Kerr, 39). As the people's history movement slowed down in the 1990s, scholars shared their critiques. A few scholars regarded public history projects as “pluralist and populist" with, "notions of American history, had avoided difficult historical questions and needed to 'sharpen their modes of historical analysis.'" (Kerr, 40). The last section of this article is dedicated to Daniel Kerr's personal work with oral history.

Reflections on Black Public History: Past, Present, Future by Pero Gaglo Dagbovie

This article by Pero Gaglo Dagbovie examines the historiography of Black public history. Although Black public history emerged during the 1980s, Dagbovie believes that it is an understudied field. Since Black history challenges White racism and empowers African American communities, Dagbovie states that "much of Black history, though it is a distinct field and discipline in its own right, could be considered public history" (Dagbovie, 527). In his article he places the origins of Black public history in the antebellum period with abolitionists. These activists produced “scholarship for a literate Black public and a broader educated White public” (Dagbovie, 533). They developed historical narratives--before the professionalization of history emerged--for the Black and White general public. These narratives continued into the post emancipation period when Black historians and reformers published more scientific historical scholarship. During the Jim Crow era, Carter G. Woodson and the Association for the Study of Negro Life and History “were at the forefront of the early Black History Movement that could at various levels be considered a Black public history movement” (Dagbovie, 534). Woodson and his peers connected academic history to public history. They published books, conducted programs, and Black history kits. In doing so, Woodson shaped the field of Black history. As for the current state of Black studies, Dagbovie points out that historians continue to "seek to make Black history both relevant to the present and this-worldly in orientation" (Dagbovie, 537). This can be easily found in popular culture including television, motion pictures, music, literature, and accredited national museums. Dagbovie successfully makes the case that Black history is public history.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

2/29: What Can "The Public Historian" Teach Us About the State of the Field?

1/18: Historic Eatonville and the Fight to Preserve “America’s First Incorporated Black Town” in the 21st Century

1/25: The History Harvest as Community-Engaged, "Hands-On" History