3/14: The Inclusive Handbook

About the handbook:

The Inclusive Historians Handbook is sponsored by the American Association for State and Local History (AASLH) and the National Council on Public History (NCPH). The handbook was published in 2019. The purpose of which is to give advice, offer perspectives, and share practices that promote an inclusive history. 

Diversity and Inclusion: 

There has been a growing discourse in public history that there is “limited scope of representation within the historical narrative.” Thus conversations about diversity and inclusion have increased over the years. This part of the handbook focuses on “drawing distinctions between the terms and further exploring inclusion, both in terms of social sinclusion and workplace inclusion” (Taylor). Because diversity is a broad term that can many different things, diversity and inclusion consultant Michael L. Wheeler defined it as a dynamic force that drives change. In addition to defining diversity, author Chris Taylor define inclusion as “whether members of diverse groups feel valued and respected within an organization, project, or social system” (Taylor). There is a distinction between diversity and inclusion. Diversity is a noun, and inclusion is a verb. There can be diversity without inclusion. It is important to have inclusion as it “refers to how we leverage diversity within a system to create a fair, equitable, and healthy environment which leads to higher performing groups.” (Taylor). The focal point of this essay is inclusion as a practice, experience, and philosophy. Taylor argues that historians should learn inclusive practices. He also touches on shared authority between scholars and individuals as it is important for them to participate in public history as their authentic selves (Taylor). Finally, inclusion as a philosophy (like Critical Race Theory, Queer Theory, Postcolonialism, etc.) helps us recognize power structures that have worked against marginalized peoples.

Historic Preservation 

This entry discusses how historic preservation has changed over the years and how practitioners have begun to push back on the limited criteria of the National Register of Historic Places’ nomination process. This push away is due to practitioners using inclusivity by focusing on stories of marginalized communities, protecting local architecture, and preserving, “sites of the recent past,” and promoting “the protection of intangible heritage” (Chhaya). The goal of historic preservation now is to promote inclusivity, community input, and environmentalism. Early history of historic preservation came from the protection key sites such as George Washington’s home and the Pennsylvania Railroad Station in New York City (Chhaya). These initiatives promoted the creation of the National Historic Preservation Act in 1966 also the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation and National Register of Historic Places. The author argues that a key element of inclusivity in historic preservation is switching the focus from places to the people, meaning protecting communities who have lived in those places (Chhaya). One area of interest for the National Trust of Historic Preservation is ReUrbanism. ReUrbanism focuses on “creating equity in neighborhood development and planning, and derive from a broader conversation with the field about preservation planning in urban areas” (Chhaya). Shared authority and community engagement are important commitments to ReUrbanism. Finally, the last important change to preservation is storytelling. The author argues that past methods and practices do not include storytelling. For inclusive preservation is it important to hear the stories from people of the community which create intangible heritages (Chhaya). 

View from the Field: The Challenges to Being Inclusive in Museum Collections

This entry discusses the lack of diversity and inclusion in museum collections. The author Marion Carpenter argues that this is due to lack of diversity in collections and curatorial departments. Through this entry Carpenter, hopes to make aware of “these issues around inclusivity in collections, spark discussion, and speak up in defense of proper cultural representation” (Carpenter). Carpenter talks about her own experiences in curatoring artifacts that deal with sensitive subjects of race such as racially offensive African American toys from the 1930s and 40s. These artifacts received little attention and proper care from the curatorial staff at her museum. Carpenter worked on including these toys in an exhibit targeted for children with historical context on how they contributed to racial prejudices and discrimination, but the curator of her museum only wanted to have the toys on display. Carpenter recognized that there were no handbooks or guides to what she was experiencing. It also didn’t help that the curator was unmoving on her position. Her continuous challenge of the curator led the museum to not display the toys at all. After 12 years of museum curatorial experience, Carpenter set out to educate history students on the importance of object documentation (Carpenter). In her lectures and workshops she incorporates a postcard of a lynching “to teach other museum professionals how to accept racially sensitive materials” (Carpenter). For the prevention and advocacy against discrimination in collections, Carpenter says that it is the “duty of the museum to care for all collection(s)” (Carpenter).

Thoughts on Inclusive Collections: 

I was at the Smithsonian of American History in D.C. almost ten years ago and they had this huge room with a collection of toys and I remember seeing dolls on display and I vividly remember seeing racially offensive African American dolls. I can’t recall if there was any context below them. 

I know at the Orange County Regional History Center in their black communities exhibit, tucked in a corner, there is a display of a Klansmen robe and underneath it talks about the assassination of Harry T. Moore and the threat of violence from members of the klan. It’s really eerie to look at and I think its placement in the exhibit has a lot to say about the sensitivity of the subject. It’s tucked away in a corner that is easily missable, and if you do find it it’s very jarring. But it almost seems like they are downplaying the violence and every day threats African Americans would face during the Jim Crow era. You know it’s in the corner for a reason and now out in a display case in the middle of the exhibit. I was just wondering what they were thinking in doing that, is it a message saying “the Klan doesn’t define the African American experience”? Because Florida during the Jim Crow era had the highest number of lynchings and the most famous postcard of a lynching came from Fort Lauderdale, so they had to be important. This also makes me question the diversity of the curatorial and collections staff at the museum.

All-in-all, I think this entry brings up good questions on the inclusivity of collections in regional/state/national museums or subject specific museums (Black history, Jewish, LGBTQ).


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

2/29: What Can "The Public Historian" Teach Us About the State of the Field?

1/18: Historic Eatonville and the Fight to Preserve “America’s First Incorporated Black Town” in the 21st Century

1/25: The History Harvest as Community-Engaged, "Hands-On" History