3/28 Reading: Thomas Cauvin, Public History: A Textbook of Practice / Historians as Consultants and Advisors

A Textbook of Practice

Thomas Cauvin begins the introduction by talking about how popular history is in mainstream culture such as television and game shows. However, he says there's a lack of authority meaning that historians aren’t a part of popular historical reflection. He cites Robert Rosenzweig and David Thelen who conducted a survey on the presence of the past in American everyday life in 1998. They said that people prefer creating their own versions of the past rather than seek those prepared by others (Cauvin, 1). Cauvin argues that “historians may be completely absent from the most popular representations of the past.” (Cauvin, 1). He gives a popular example of people using genealogical websites that generally don’t have any historian collaboration. He is touching on the divide between being a traditional historian or public historian. In doing so, he is reasserting the need for history and historians (Cauvin, 2). Cauvin also “aims to show how historians can participate in public understanding of the past.” (Cauvin, 2). Essentially arguing in favor of public historians. 

He then goes over a brief history of public historians. He says although the public history movement emerged in the 1970s, historians’ public roles and activities are much older (Cauvin, 2). He places the origins in scientific history, Leopold von Ranke, and the professionalization of history during the late 19th century (objectivity, historicism, primary sources, and factual analysis). He goes on to talk about historians in the “ivory tower” who are disconnected from other intellectuals and popular audiences which emerged in the late 19th century (Cauvin, 3). This has been a common theme up until recently, but Cauvin is challenging this by saying historians have always addressed public issues especially as local, government, and contracted historians (Cauvin, 5). 

The emergence of public history in the 20th century dealt mostly with local history. But new approaches and fields in history surfaced during the social movements of the 1950s and 60s. Cauvin states that minority rights and discrimination had an impact on historians thus the emergence of social history (Cauvin, 7). This interest in people also provided the need for oral histories. 

At first public history was defined outside of academia but overtime it highlighted the need for historians to engage with broader communities beyond traditional academic settings. To be a public historian you still need to acquire specific skills, training, and an awareness of the challenges involved in working with diverse audiences. Cauvin then goes on to highlight shared authority, the uses of the past, and the institutionalization/internationalization of public history. Finally, he argues for the academic study of public history thus the reasoning for his textbook on public history practice. 


Relation to the #LandBack movement:

The Land Back movement is rooted in public memory of the past. Since origins of the movement emerged from the community level it is similar to how Cauvin asserts that historians have not had a role in public discourse on history. Using this textbook of practice, I am able to identify my role as the historian in providing historical reflection to Eatonville activists use of the “#LandBack'' campaign in arguing for the return of the Hungerford school property. In addition, the Hungerford School project as a whole is an example of civic engagement with social justice components. I will be able to support local community history and promote shared authority with my skills and expertise.




Comments

Popular posts from this blog

2/29: What Can "The Public Historian" Teach Us About the State of the Field?

1/18: Historic Eatonville and the Fight to Preserve “America’s First Incorporated Black Town” in the 21st Century

1/25: The History Harvest as Community-Engaged, "Hands-On" History